• Upgrade earnings estimates and FV on higher NIMs; reiterate Buy We raise our 2016-17 net income estimates for Credit Agricole Egypt (CAE) to reflect mainly higher net interest margin assumptions following the increase in policy rates in mid-March and consequently in yields on government securities. We raise our FV to EGP26.7 (from EGP24.9), and reiterate our Buy rating as our FV implies 21% potential upside. While the share price has had a good run, up c16% over the past three months, we believe valuation multiples do not look demanding: it trades at a low P/E of 6.1x in 2016e, a P/B of 1.9x and we expect 2016e ROE of 33.8% (from 35.8% in 2015). In addition, it has an attractive dividend yield of 8.6%. • Large 2016e P/B discount to CIB, despite similar profitability CAE trades at a discount of c20% on P/B and 34% on P/E for 2016e to CIB. On a trailing basis, the P/B discount to CIB is c18%, and it has narrowed only slightly from 21% earlier in the year. Historically (over the past 8 years), the discount has been in the range of 26%. This was to some extent justified by CIB having superior profitability, however this is no longer the case: CAE has an ROE which is 300-200bps higher than that of CIB in 2016-17e. We believe there is room for the P/B discount to CIB to narrow further. • Loan growth slowing; wider NIMs to drive double-digit earnings growth CAE’s loans grew 11% Y-o-Y, with retail loan growth strong at 19%. We believe that loan growth will be slower this year, mainly as a result of new caps on debt burden ratios imposed by the CBE (maximum of 35% of net monthly salary from January 2016). NIMs will be, in our view, the key driver of earnings growth this year. We note that CAE’s earnings growth momentum (+10% Y-o-Y) is likely to be slower than CIB (+25% Y-o-Y) in 2016, as we believe CAE will not actively chase deposit growth in an environment of slowing lending demand, as it does not solely focus on growing deposits to invest in T-Bills and T-Bonds. Government securities account for 27% of CAE’s total assets, versus 43% for CIB.
Elena Sanchez-Cabezudo, CFA Rajae Aadel
This website uses cookies to make the site work, to understand if the site is working well, how it is being used, to connect to social media sites (such as Facebook and Twitter) and to collect information useful to allow us and our partners to provide you with more relevant ads . Some cookies are essential to make the site work, but you can control how we use non-essential cookies at any time by clicking the “ON/OFF” button next to each category. For more information about the cookies used on this site, see Privacy Policy.
Decide which cookies you want to allow.
Strictly Necessary
These cookies are essential in order to enable you to move around our website and use its features, such as accessing secure areas of our website. Without these cookies, any services on our Site you wish to access cannot be provided.
Analytical/performance cookies
Visitors use our website, for instance which pages you go to most often, and if you get error messages from web pages.