Agthia 3Q16: Flattish earnings as impact of flour & feed subsidy removal slowly kicks in; no major surprises
Agthia reported its 3Q16 results with no major surprises. Earnings were flattish (+1% Y-o-Y; weakest growth since 2011) and slightly above our numbers (+6%) mainly on better-margins. Revenue was up only 3% Y-o-Y (in line) as weak flour & feed sales (-6% Y-o-Y) offset decent growth in water & beverages and food segments. Gross margin increased c3.6pp Y-o-Y to 32.9% (vs. EFGe of 32.4%) as all segments saw margin gains (flour & feed +c80bps; water & beverages +c6.4pp; food +c14.5pp). Gross profit was thus up 15% Y-o-Y (+2% vs. EFGe). EBITDA, however, was flattish (+4% Y-o-Y; +8% vs. EFGe) as SG&A costs rose 26% Y-o-Y (in line) partly on Al Bayan consolidation (9M16 SG&A costs +33%, +19% ex. Al Bayan), which has higher distribution costs than the Al Ain water business. Below are highlights of the company’s three segments: Flour & Feed (c53% of 3Q16 revenue) saw top-line fall 6% Y-o-Y as volumes were weak in July and August (especially in feed) as customers withheld orders expecting a subsidy removal reversal as well as a high level of subsidized inventory in the market. Feed saw the subsidy removed in full for municipalities and distributors (c60% of feed volumes) for the whole quarter with Agthia launching new products including a value range and launching some marketing support to mitigate the impact. In flour, the subsidy was removed in full for retail, trade and catering (c32% of flour volumes) from 1 Sept 2016 with the company introducing a value range for trade and catering (lower-margin) and raising retail prices in line with market while introducing a fighter band. Bakeries (c35% of flour sales) remain subsidized with subsidy to be removed gradually from 31Aug 2017. Water & Beverage revenue (c39%) was up 10% Y-o-Y driven by strong water performance that continued to gain market share (record-high 25.3% volume share in June-July 2016 reading, over 9pp above second player) as well as the Al Bayan acquisition (consolidated from 4Q15; 9M16 water revenue +27%, +12% ex Al Bayan). Alpin (Turkey) saw top-line +25% in 9M16 while losses reduced by 62%. Capri-Sun remained challenged on a declining juice market and new school regulations (9M16 juice revenue -2%). Food division (c8%) performed strongly with 3Q16 revenue +56% Y-o-Y and gross margin of 12.6% (vs. a gross loss in 3Q15) partly as margins continued to improve for yogurt (over 7.5pp Y-o-Y in 9M16) and emerging categories (bakery, tomato paste, etc; 9M16 revenue +31%, net losses -52%). A decent set of results in light of the subsidy change in flour & feed in Abu Dhabi with no major surprises. We reiterate our Neutral rating as we expect earnings growth to be challenging in the short-term given the gradual subsidy removal (barring any acquisitions). (company, Hatem Alaa, CFA, Nada Amin) Agthia (AD): AED6.00 as of 1 Nov 2016, Rating: Neutral, FV: AED7.15 per share, MCap: USD981mn, AGTHIA UH / AGTH.AD
This website uses cookies to make the site work, to understand if the site is working well, how it is being used, to connect to social media sites (such as Facebook and Twitter) and to collect information useful to allow us and our partners to provide you with more relevant ads . Some cookies are essential to make the site work, but you can control how we use non-essential cookies at any time by clicking the “ON/OFF” button next to each category. For more information about the cookies used on this site, see Privacy Policy.
Decide which cookies you want to allow.
Strictly Necessary
These cookies are essential in order to enable you to move around our website and use its features, such as accessing secure areas of our website. Without these cookies, any services on our Site you wish to access cannot be provided.
Analytical/performance cookies
Visitors use our website, for instance which pages you go to most often, and if you get error messages from web pages.